The realization that the dead girl is not her sister sinks in.
The first movie of Ms. Byrne’s that i’ll write about is 2006’s “The Dead Girl”. This movie is Karen Moncrief’s follow-up to “Blue Car”, a story about an English Teacher’s seduction of his High School student. Its also been screened at AFI and nominated at the Independent Spirit Awards.
This time around, she makes a movie about a prostitute who is killed by a serial killer. Her death reverberates and affects the lives of three strangers as well as her mother, mostly for the good.
Its a movie made up of five seemingly unrelated vignettes, around 17 minutes each. Each story is about a woman who is affected by the death. All the actors in this film do a wonderful job — each chapter is very sad and heavy, but thanks to the acting and writing, you feel good like after a good cry. There is nothing like grief, tragedy and the promise of redemption to make for good dramatic fodder. This movie is like catnip for actors.
Let me mention briefly the acting caliber involved. Aussie Toni Collete plays the woman who finds the body, which helps her free herself her abusive mother (Piper Laurie) and connect with a new love (Giovanni Ribisi). Mary Beth Hurt stars as ‘the wife’ who learns a terrible secret about her husband (Nick Searcy). Marcia Gay Harden is the dead girl’s mother who learn ex-post about her daugther and grand-daughter from another prostitute (Kerry Washington). Brittany Murphy is the dead girl, who is killed by a serial killer as she tries to get to her daughter.
Listening to the DVD commentary, its clear that Ms. Moncrief didn’t have problems getting the performances she wanted!
But i really rented this film for Rose Byrne, and is now my favorite of her dramatic performances. Ms. Moncrief calls her ‘magnificent’ and that her beauty is something that renaissance painters would die for. Even without makeup (which is true in the film), she is arresting.
Rose plays Leah, a forensics grad student who believes that the dead girl is really her sister who was abducted some 15 years ago. While the rest of her family (her mother is played by Mary Steenburgen) continues to search, she is now in the grip of a powerful depression because she hasn’t been able to live her own life. With the arrival of the dead girl that she has reason to believe is her sister, her burden is lifted and is able to continue with her life. But her hopes are dashed because the dead girl isn’t really her sister. This time, thanks of the promise of life and love (symbolized by the incipient relationship with James Franco), she is able to finally grieve.
Its a simple story and the most accessible to me because, while i’ve never had the fortune of befriending a prostitute, i can imagine grieving over a loss and trying to move on.
As an amateur student of film, i also noted that Ms Moncrief used a few stylistic tricks to great effect. To capture the idea of loneliness and sadness, she used a color palatte of blues as well as shooting Rose in frames or against negative space (as if to show her isolation). Very cool. See a couple of shots below:
Here, she is seperated by a frame.
Notice the negative space on the left.
The shots above are from the second scene from the movie where she confesses her loneliness and hopes to her psychiatrist. She describes what she imagines ‘moving on’ would look like. In the commentary, Ms Moncrief was full of praise for Rose, particularly for this scene. She said that while this scene was being shot, the set would hush up because they knew great dramatic work was being done.
When she suspects that the dead girl is her sister, the shots changes, and more color is added in. In the shot below, she talks with fellow student James Franco and surrenders to his warmth and humor.
Note the lights around her face, as color enters her life again.
When her hope is dashed, she collapses again into self-pity. Below, she is overcome with sadness and the director shoots her again in a frame. Note her reflection on the window and her eyes welling up.

But this time around, she fights back. She argues with her mother and says that its time to let go. Her chapter concludes with Leah burning the newspaper clippings of her sister’s dissappearance and finally begins grieving.
She looks on as she burns the clippings.
In this final shot, she calls James Franco’s character after burning the clippings, and says “Please help me” Great Ending!