A fan of the show will enjoy this movie, as i did. Three of the main characters traveled through familiar arcs for 2 hours, with the exception of charlotte, who exists here, as in most of the series, to remind us of the romantic ideal — she’s got her dreams fullfilled by the end of the show, and the movie gives her character icing on the perfect cake that is her life, a ‘deux ex machina’ of miraculous proportions. Other than that, her role is comic, and is lovingly brought down (poop jokes, anyone?) for a good chunk of the movies’ long middle of Carrie’s recovery.
I appreciate Mr. King’s ending for Samantha. The logic of the character dictates that it ends. Presumably, one can imagine a different ending, but i for one am glad they stuck to she stuck to her identity, as a good archetype would.
Samantha’s story is part of the movies’ central theme. As i’ve noted elsewhere, the thematic nature of the show is characteristic of Sex and the City. Many a critic has said that the theme is forgiveness, and they would be right. But to this, something must be added, which i believe is larger and more interesting: the folly of labels. Throughout the movie labels were bandied about, and not just the clothes and the bags, but for relationships and people. From boyfriend to ‘manfriend’, from cheater to wife… the movie is full of labels that we’d love and/or hate to attach to ourselves and to other people. Samantha hated the label of ‘woman who live for a man’, while Big hated the ceremony of a Vogue labelled wedding. By the end, the movie suggests that we get hurt when others reject the labels we force on others. And when other people ask for forgiveness, we ultimately grant it when we see through the labels to glimpse at the real treasure underneath.
I’m surprised many critics hate the superficial nature of Carrie, her selfishness, when it is exactly this point that the movie (and the TV show!) is trying to address. The TV show is extremely conservative, and its asking its viewers to look beneath labels to the good stuff underneath that never changes. This is why i’ve always wondered about the religious/conservative backlash — other than the short sex scenes, this movie is all about commitment and deep friendship.
A final note about time. A part of me felt that, as a comedy, it was a bit too long– i first thought they could have cut out the New Year/Winter sequence. But whats interesting about the Northern hemisphere is that one can SEE time pass through the seasons. That was important as time is a necessary ingredient in forgiveness. So, in a sense the move had to show time pass, that Carrie and Miranda’s could go endure their deepest melancholy in the winter (as this season usually depicts in movies), so they can live again for Fashion week, the movies’ version of new life in the spring.